Free Up or Control?
Two Possible Options for Trust
Will the future require us to live
with suspicion and distrust toward others?
Or can we envision an alternative future?
“Free up or control?” will be key to
exploring the possible futures of trust.
Two options to shape
trust in the future
We assumed that sei-katsu-sha will manage to navigate this crisis to avoid the risk of a society of distrust by finding new ways of building trust for themselves.
In other words, trust will shift from something that can be taken for granted
to something to be created on our own.
That said, sei-katsu-sha are not moving in the same direction.
We believe that sei-katsu-sha will create diverse forms of trust rather than a single model.
Accordingly, we developed multiple future scenarios.
This is because individual sei-katsu-sha have substantially different visions of:
- how to build relationships with others
- how to handle their own information
These are the two underlying factors for building trust amid the changing personal relationships and ways of communicating in the future.
The outcome will hinge on the choice between two value options:
“free up” or “control”.
Changing “with whom” to build trust
Will we free up or control
our relationships?
In a future with physical and psychological distancing, the first question to ask ourselves in order to create new trust may be: “With whom should we build trust at all?”
The values of sei-katsu-sha are now deeply divided: some prefer connecting with as many people as possible even as such opportunities continue to decrease, while others prefer closer relationships with like-minded people even as people themselves develop increasingly diverse values.
Will we free up or control our relationships with others? The shape of trust in the future depends on which option we take in building personal relationships going forward.
Seek to build a limited network of trust by deepening relationships with
like-minded people, focusing on common ground or psychological affinity.
Seek to build a wider network of trust by expanding relationships to include different types of people, focusing on differences and diversity.
Enriching my world by interacting
with a limited number of people
Enriching my world by interacting
with a wide variety of people
Feeling joy
in common ground or affinity with others
Feeling joy
in differences with others
Building narrower and deeper relations
with specific people
Building wider and shallower relations
with various people
Building personal relationships
with like-minded people
Building personal relationships
with different types of people
Human capacity is limited. I would be happier if I could limit my relationships to those that I really care about.
(Female, 23, Saitama)
Personal relationships are exhausting.
I would rather focus on relationships with specific people to leave enough energy for my job and hobbies.
(Male, 44, Hokkaido)
Given the diversification of values, I do not think I can get along with everybody.
(Male, 59, Kagawa)
I would be a better person if I could embrace a wider range of values. Always being with people like myself would limit my potential.
(Female, 34, Hiroshima)
It will be easier to connect with everybody as social media helps us reach a wider variety of people.
(Male, 50, Shizuoka)
I don’t know whose help I will need as I get old. A wider network of personal relationships would help.
(Female, 60, Niigata)
Source: Hakuhodo Institute of Life and Living
Changing “with what” to build trust
Will we free up or control
our information?
Getting to know each other better by communicating information about ourselves is one of the essential conditions for building trust.
As information is invisible and too visible at the same time, however, sei-katsu-sha are not sure if they should disclose more information or keep more of it secret.
Will we free up or control our own information? The intensity and function of trust will depend on how we manage the way we communicate information.
Seek to build spontaneous and flexible trust by disclosing
personal information selectively depending on the recipient.
Seek to build an equal and equitable network of trust by disclosing personal
information without selection or modification regardless of the recipient.
Better to hide who you really are
Better to share everything about yourself
Reducing confrontation and friction
by exchanging personal information selectively
Reducing misinformation and doubtn
by exchanging personal information proactively
Changing your identity and personality
depending on the other person or context
Showing who you really are regardless
of the other person or context
Keeping personal data
to yourself for optimal utilization
Providing personal information
for the good of society
I don’t feel the need to share everything about myself. Going with the flow makes everybody happy.
(Female, 32, Kagawa)
I have too many inferiority complexes to show my true colors.
(Male, 33, Osaka)
I already have more anonymous relationships online than in-person exchanges. This trend will continue. I believe more people are now playing appropriate roles or disguising themselves depending on the other person or context.
(Female, 50, Shizuoka)
I do not want to hide the fact that I belong to a sexual minority. I want people to recognize people like me exist, even if they don’t understand us.
(Female, 33, Osaka)
You should disclose your personal information from the outset. Everyone will eventually get to know who you really are anyway.
(Male, 34, Osaka)
I cannot change my identity depending on the other person. I want to tell the truth before I get involved in any relationship.
(Male, 58, Fukuoka)
Source: Hakuhodo Institute of Life and Living
Four scenarios of trust in the future
We developed four future scenarios to indicate the possible directions of trust that sei-katsu-sha may follow. In view of the two value options and the two requirements for building trust, we asked the following questions:
Will you free up or control your relationships?
Will you free up or control your information?
By combining the answers to these two questions, we obtained the following four scenarios of trust indicating possible future directions of values among sei-katsu-sha:
・Sei-katsu-sha value building wide trust with a variety of people by selectively disclosing their personal information.
・In this future, people create trust by skillfully crafting and selecting their identity and personal information to be shared,
depending on the preferences and values of the interlocutor.
・Sei-katsu-sha feel as if they are freely living multiple lives by partially disclosing their identity and
flexibly engaging with a variety of interlocutors in a diverse society.
・Sei-katsu-sha value building trust widely with a variety of people by telling exactly who they are.
・In this future, all people create trust by publicly disclosing their correct personal information.
・Through this open information, sei-katsu-sha collaborate with both acquaintances and strangers based on a proper understanding of each other’s situations and needs, so as to improve convenience in their life and the whole community.
through shared ideals and purpose
・Sei-katsu-sha value building secure trust with a limited number of people by selectively disclosing their personal information.
・In this future, people build trust by presenting their unwavering ideals and purpose, and this is the sole basis of their trust.
・Sei-katsu-sha pursue their objectives in solid relationships with their peers while not infringing too much on each other’s personal space, so as to live an independent life at some distance from each other.
・Sei-katsu-sha value building secure trust with a limited number of people by telling exactly who they are.
・In this future, people create trust by frequently sharing detailed information about themselves with specific people.
・Sei-katsu-sha feel secure in partnerships with people who know them very well while sometimes accepting bold advice from the interlocutors, so as to live a life full of challenges and adventures.